Monday, January 11, 2016

Wintertime Bean Soup

This is a rerun post, but it is so perfect for this week. Bean soup is a staple at our house for these cold winter evenings. There's nothing like that homey-salty-warming aroma as the soup cooks in the crock pot all day long!

Another reason why this recipe is appropriate for this week is that the long-awaited release of "Hannah's Choice" is imminent!

You can order Hannah's Choice here ( or
here (

I love this series, The Journey to Pleasant Prairie. It was born out of a quest to understand why my family was no longer Amish, and that quest opened a lot of doors and will provide fodder for many stories to come!

So as we celebrate the pending release (January 19th!), settle back and enjoy this post from a few years ago:

The western view from our house at 3 pm. Nearly sunset.

“Winter is the time for comfort, for good food and warmth, for the touch of a friendly hand and for a talk beside the fire: it is the time for home.” 
― Edith Sitwell

It is the turn of the year. The days are short, the evenings dark and long.

In our part of the world, the sun rises in the southeast, skims the rooftops of the houses to our south, and sets behind the Hills in the southwest. 

The mid-afternoon light throws long shadows as we explore the shore of Sylvan Lake - the summer playground deserted this time of year.

By 5:00, Orion starts his journey across the southern sky and the shades are drawn against the cold night outside.

This is the time for soup and homemade bread - food that warms the belly and the spirit.

Today's soup is bean soup. Not a fancy dish, but nothing tastes better on a cold winter night.

I have no recipe for this soup - it would be like asking for a recipe for scrambled eggs! It's been a wintertime staple in my family since long before I was born.

The main ingredient is beans. 

I always use Navy Beans, or small white beans, but you can use your favorite.

Now don't turn up your nose at the lowly bean! Just check out this nutritional powerhouse:

Beans are a good source of
1) Protein
2) Complex carbohydrates
3) Fiber - both soluble and insoluble
4) Calcium
5) Potassium
6) Folate (a B vitamin)

It's easy to prepare the beans for cooking. Start the night before by soaking two cups of beans in about a gallon of water mixed with two tablespoons vinegar. If you have hard water (water with a lot of minerals in it), use filtered or distilled water for soaking and cooking your beans.

Why the vinegar? It helps reduce that gassy side effect beans can have.

The next morning, drain and rinse the beans thoroughly. Now they're ready to use.

Beans take a long time to cook and they absorb a lot of water, so give yourself plenty of time. I always use my slow cooker, but you can also cook them on top of the stove over low heat (be sure to stir them occasionally). Either way, check the beans every couple hours to make sure they haven't cooked dry.

I use broth instead of water to cook my bean soup - it adds flavor as well as nutrition. Today I'm using ham broth and chicken broth (about six cups for two cups of dry beans), but you can also use vegetable broth, leftover water from boiling potatoes, or whatever you might have on hand.

Always add onions to your soup, again for flavor and nutrition, but from there on the soup is very versatile.

We have leftover ham from Christmas in the refrigerator, so I diced up about a cup of that and added it in. You can also add carrots or potatoes (or both). Some people add in mashed potatoes.

Let the soup cook for a good 10 to 12 hours in the slow cooker - maybe four to six hours on the stove.

Taste your soup before adding salt and pepper - if you've used ham or ham broth, you'll probably have enough salt already.

If you add salt, wait until the very end of cooking to put it in. (Salt keeps the fiber in the beans from breaking down while cooking.) 

Serve your soup with fruit or veggies, and lots of crackers.

My husband likes these little gems - he calls them "fabulous crackers" - but I like regular saltines.

Remember I said this soup has been a family staple for years? While doing some research for my next book, I found out that for the 18th century Amish in Pennsylvania (my grandparents six and seven generations ago...), bean soup was a Sunday tradition.

The Amish in those days didn't drive buggies, or wagons, or carriages to church. They walked.

It could be a six mile walk to the house where the Sabbath Meeting was being held, and before the families would start the long walk home in the afternoon, they were given a meal - something simple, warm, filling and cheap. Bean soup.

I can just imagine a log home filled to the brim with Amish families, some of them still grieving loved ones they had lost on the long journey across the Atlantic in ships called the "Charming Nancy" and "Love and Unity". Old men with gray beards, women in their bonnets and capes, children with cheeks rosy from the cold outside and the heat inside the house...and all day long smelling the fragrance from the big kettle of bean soup simmering on the hearth.

And you thought you had a hard time concentrating on the sermon!


  1. I love bean soup, and I love the family history behind this. It intrigues me to look back and see how choices made a century or more ago, affect my life today. It's amazing, isn't it? We aren't born, nor do we thrive in a bubble, but a connection to old, new and yet-to-come.

    I love this!

    1. It really makes me pause - how are my decisions today going to affect the future generations of our family?

      Of course, feeding them good food and leaving a legacy of family recipes is a good place to start! :)

  2. After a weekend of unseasonably warm temps and torrential rains we hit a flash freeze and it's bitterly cold this morning -- the perfect day for some homemade bean soup. Thanks for the inspiration...though it might have to be lentil because I don't think I have any beans. Ah well, hot soup and crusty bread is winter's comfort food.

    So excited to read Hannah's Choice. Thank goodness for inspiring ancestors and creative minds.

    1. Those sudden weather changes can be brutal, and we have a lot of them here in the Black Hills. Our area is #1 in the country for the most unpredictable weather.

      I like the interesting variety, but my friends with RA and other auto-immune conditions really suffer. :(

      I'm glad you have lentils to make a hearty soup!

  3. Jan, this sounds so yummy. I'm glad you shared it again!

    Congrats on the release coming soon!!

    1. Thanks, Missy!

      I didn't only share the recipe again, I'm making it for supper for tomorrow night :)

  4. Jan, I love this post.
    First because I'm really looking forward to that "imminent release".
    Second, I very nearly did a bean soup for Wednesday, but at the last minute I made something else instead so the bean soup shall wait.

    I think Orion has always been my favorite constellation - probably because he was so easy to recognize. I can still see him most nights, even with all the city lights.

    1. That's one thing I love about Orion. Everywhere we've lived, he's so bright that we can always find him. The hunter of the winter sky....